In a shocking turn of events, former WWE NXT wrestler Knuckles Madson, born Kevin Nickel, was brutally murdered just three days after his divorce was finalized, leaving behind an eight-year-old son and a community in mourning. The 41-year-old athlete was found shot along Highway 12 in Benton County, Arkansas, on July 11, suffering a fatal gunshot wound to the abdomen. He was rushed to the hospital but succumbed to his injuries shortly after.
Authorities have arrested two individuals in connection with this tragic case: Michael Hogue, 51, and Amanda Penny, 40, Nickel’s ex-wife. Hogue faces a first-degree murder charge, while Penny has been charged as an accomplice to murder. Both suspects also face firearm possession charges. The arrests came after a prolonged investigation that left many questions unanswered, particularly for Nickel’s grieving family.
Witnesses report that tensions had been escalating between Nickel and Hogue, who was reportedly Penny’s new boyfriend. Just days before the shooting, Nickel had expressed concerns to authorities about Hogue being around his son, citing the latter’s criminal history. This conflict, combined with the emotional fallout from the recent divorce, created a powder keg of animosity.
The timeline leading to Nickel’s death paints a disturbing picture. On the night of the shooting, Penny allegedly claimed that Nickel had broken into their home and vandalized property, which Nickel denied. Instead, he reportedly told a deputy that Hogue had shot him. This crucial statement, made moments before his death, is being treated as a “dying declaration” and could play a pivotal role in the prosecution’s case.
As the investigation unfolds, details about the night of the shooting have emerged, including conflicting narratives from the suspects. Hogue asserts that he and Penny were merely driving when they encountered Nickel, who allegedly brandished a gun, leading to a physical altercation. However, evidence collected at the scene, including surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts, suggests otherwise. Investigators found two baseball bats near the scene, one belonging to Nickel’s son, raising further questions about the nature of the confrontation.
The emotional toll on Nickel’s family is palpable. His mother, Susan Kinderman, expressed her desire for clarity, stating, “I just hope that we have a lot of answers. I know that the justice system will work.” The wrestling community is equally devastated, with tributes pouring in from fans and fellow wrestlers alike, mourning the loss of a man described as a beloved friend and a dedicated father.
As the legal proceedings begin, both Hogue and Penny are scheduled for arraignment on January 5, 2026. The court has ordered them to refrain from any contact with Nickel’s family or their young son, emphasizing the seriousness of the charges against them. The case not only highlights the tragic intersection of personal turmoil and violence but also serves as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences that can arise from unresolved conflicts.
As the community grapples with this heartbreaking loss, the search for justice continues. The upcoming court dates will undoubtedly bring more revelations, but for now, the legacy of Knuckles Madson is one of love, family, and the profound impact of a life cut short.
